Meteorite or “Meteor-wrong”?

Posted: December 16, 2011 - 13:00 , by Ian Nicklin
Natural History, What's New, Meteorites, Mineralogy, Research | Comments (9) | Comment

ROM Earth Scientists receive dozens of requests each year to identify possible meteorites. This is especially the case when there is a spectacular fireball similar to the one which recently streaked across southern Ontario on December 12 of this year (the video was captured by astronomers at the University of Western Ontario). Do you think you have found a space rock?

Meteorites have an other-worldly appearance because, well, they are from other worlds. As a result, freshly fallen meteorites often stand out from the run-of-the-mill Earth-rocks you encounter. They typically have a fusion crust: a blackened, charred-looking exterior. This crust is the result of the meteor making it’s fiery passage through our atmosphere when the exterior of the stone is white-hot. During this period tremendous amounts of molten material are ripped from the surface which also produces a gouged, dimpled surface. Such a surface is often referred to as being ‘thumb printed’ since it resembles a piece of clay in which someone has repeatedly pressed their thumb, creating divots. The Greek term is regmaglypt but thumb printed is easier to say!

Many types of meteorites are also magnetic. Unfortunately there are any number of objects – both natural and manmade – that can mimic some or all of these features which we often refer to as ‘meteor-wrongs’. Over the next few installments we will discuss and show examples of some of the more typical meteor-wrongs that we often see. If you’d like to see one of the best selections of ‘meteor-rights’ on public display then be sure to stop by the Teck Suite of Galleries: Earth’s Treasures on your next visit to the ROM. Our meteorite display is second to none.

The number one, all-time, King of meteor-wrongs is slag. Slag is an industrial by-product usually left over from the refining of iron or other metals. Probably 90% of what we see as potential meteorites is some form of slag. It’s easy to understand why. It is very striking in appearance and usually appears out of place wherever you see it. It also turns up in some of the most unlikely places (I routinely find small pieces in my garden!) making people think that it must have fallen from the sky.

Typically slag has a black, brown or brownish-red, glassy-looking surface often with patches of grey or white. Not uncommonly it also contains prominent blebs of metal. Whether there is visible metal present or not slag is also quite often very magnetic. The combination of these features can convince people that they have found a meteorite since meteorites often do have a blackened exterior and can be slightly to very magnetic. However slag is also typically magnetic to some degree due to metal left over from the smelting process. So, a blackened exterior and magnetism are definitely not enough to go on.

One feature that slag almost always has, which meteorites typically do not, is bubbles. These were created when the molten slag trapped gases released in the refining process. As the slag cooled some of the gas was trapped, leaving void spaces behind. Such voids are exceptionally rare in real meteorites – only a handful are known out of the more than 40,000 meteorites in world collections. So, bubbles are not usually a good sign.

As mentioned earlier slag has a glassy appearance because it is in fact a glass. It generally cools fairly quickly so the components it is made of have little or no time to crystallize. As a result it breaks in much the same way as bottle glass does, with the classic scallop-shaped surface also known as a conchoidal fracture. The word conchoidal comes from the Greek, and refers to the curved shape of a mussel shell. Most meteorites on the other hand break more like terrestrial rocks.

One last tell-tale feature of slag is its internal appearance. When a meteor streaks through the sky it is only melting on the surface. Its interior is generally not affected. As a result, on a broken surface a meteorite will have the darkened, fusion-crusted exterior but have an internal appearance similar to many types of Earth-rocks, or in the case of iron-nickel meteorites be a very obvious silvery-colour. Slag generally has the same texture and appearance throughout and typically also shows bubbles in the interior.

These three images demonstrate many of these features.

A closer look at a black  rock with bubbles.

charred-looking surface, yes, but bubbles...not a good sign.

A closer look at a black rock with a curved break and shiny surface.

A glassy, ‘conchoidal’ fracture and a similar appearance internally and externally (and more bubbles!)

An closer look at a true meteorite

Meteor-right! This is a piece of a rare meteorite called a diogenite. You can see the typical, charred fusion crust on the outside while the interior has a distinctly different appearance.

We encourage people to be aware of their surroundings while they are out and about, this is how discoveries are made. But bear in mind that finding a real meteorite is a very rare experience and that most of us in Southern Ontario live in areas that have seen a lot of industrial activity over the past century or more. I still don’t know why slag turns up in my garden!

If you still think you have a meteorite, bring your specimen to an ROM ID Clinic and one of our experts will take a closer look.


Comment by andy

I have a golf ball sized (suspect) meteorite that I found on the shore of Georgian Bay in Wasaga Beach. Heavier than the average stone of its size at 89 grams. It is definitely not slag and does not look at all like magnetite or hematite. Leaves a faint grey streak on unglazed material. Magnetic. No fusion crust. Black and rusty in appearance on the outside, interior is black with minute specks of metal with small whitish circular chondrites. (I sanded a small window with a belt sander) I am unable to find any pictures of the Midland meteorite for comparison as this could be a fragment of the same event. Your link to the ROM ID clinic is inoperative. How to proceed?
please be advised that I will be out of town for a few weeks returning Feb 25th.

Comment by Lead Concierge

Hello, the ROM offers 6 ID clinics a year where you can bring suspected meteorites:  February 19, April 23, June 18, August 20, October 15, December 10.  They take place between 4pm and 5:30pm. 

Comment by Kelly


My dad brings some stones discovered from the bottom of the biggest lake of China. There are already some research on these stones suggest that they may be from the comet air burst. My dad believes these are meteorites from space. Please let me know how can I bring a piece to ROM to have an expert to have a closer look ?


Comment by Lead Concierge

Visitors with rocks, gems, minerals, fossils and suspected meteorites can have them inspected at one of the six I.D. Clinics held at the ROM throughout the year.  These clinics are free however no appraisals will be done.  The next three clinics are August 19, October 14 and December 9, all between 4-5:30pm.

Comment by Stan Brooks

Good Day; My house was built in 1864, 6 years ago during my holidays I arranged to have some foundation repairs made. At about 6 feet a strange looking green-red rock was unearthed. I took it to work and showed it to my fellow licensed maintenance professionals. Everyone said it is probably a meteorite. Some parts of it are magnetic others are not. If interested I have digital pictures that I can send you.

Comment by Bill

Hello. I am very curious in knowing, if it is possible for a shiny metallic looking rock with obvious signs of melting when viewed through a digital microscope. This stone is extremely hard and appears to have blown apart and is half of the meteorite. I say this because I have viewed this stone from every angle in extremely close detail. It appears to have a face or shield formed by heading in one direction as it came through the atmosphere and then upon getting extremely hot, it blew apart into 2 halves as the one side appears to be missing. It then looks as though the stone turned and melted all around slightly before finally making it through the atmosphere and landing on earth.
This stone is very heavy with a density of 4.77. It has obvious flow lines when viewed again through the digital microscope. It also has only the "broken off side" a few tiny crevices. I have many excellent detailed pictures and some zoomed in as much as 800X.
Can you tell me please if I wanted this tested by the ROM, how large of a piece would I need to bring in or send in?

I look forward to your reply.

Thank you


Comment by Lead Concierge

Hello, the ROM offers I.D. Clinics 6 times a year.  You can bring your suspected meteorites and have them identified by ROM experts.  The next date for 2016 is December 7, 2016 from 4:00 - 5:30 pm.  Entre through the Presiden't Choice entrance on the south side of the building.  There is no charge.

Comment by Halil

I have the stones, I thought it was a meteor. magnet attracts. black colored. it's bright. there is the outside shell. look at the pictures, would you? there is tangible value ? 10 000 grams in my hand.